‘Girls’ tackles abortion; how does it compare to ‘Sex and also the City’s abortion episode?

Intercourse as well as the City‘s show finale aired eight years that are long.

but also for better or even for even even worse, HBO’s previous flagship stays pop tradition’s default point of guide for just about any activity directed at ladies. Write A tv or movie show about ladies interacting, and it’ll inevitably get in comparison to SATC. Create your characters that are main feminine urbanites, plus the evaluations have also easier. If your show is just a intimately explicit, half-hour comedy featuring four young, white, feminine New Yorkers that takes place to atmosphere on HBO? Well, for the reason that full instance, you’re simply asking because of it.

HBO’s Girls hasn’t shied far from acknowledging its glitzy predecessor.

Creator/writer/director/star/key hold Lena Dunham has stated that her system couldn’t occur without Carrie and co. In final week’s premiere, a character known as Shoshanna additionally took the liberty of revealing which SATC character she believes she many resembles. (By also bringing this up, Shoshanna proves that she’s a Charlotte.) And night that is last Girls boldly went where SATC choose to go prior to by centering its 2nd episode around a primary character’s theoretical abortion. The episode proved that while Dunham’s show is, in certain means, indebted to Intercourse, it is additionally a totally various animal.

In most cases, Intercourse as well as the City wasn’t afraid to tackle taboos. Therefore it’s surprising that the show avoided the subject of abortion until halfway through its 4th period. Within an episode called “Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda,” workaholic Miranda understands that an opportunity encounter with an ex-boyfriend has kept her with a bun into the range. She’s no intention of maintaining the child. It happens when she reveals this to the gals at brunch, sexually liberated Samantha announces, “It’s less than a desirable situation, but. We’ve all been there. I’ve had two!”

Samantha’s flippancy aside, the episode treats abortion with sensitiveness. Miranda functions outwardly confident about her choice, but secretly is not sure she’s doing the right thing. Carrie additionally reveals that while she does not regret having an abortion at 22, she’s never ever quite felt equivalent since. Although the redhead finally chooses to keep carefully the infant, her choice does not feel just like a cop-out — the show is supporting a woman’s directly to select while acknowledging that abortion is complicated and fraught. The actual only real element of the episode that really feels off is a goofy, unneeded subplot about Samantha lusting after a $4,000 Birkin case.

SATC makes use of Samantha’s search for a Birkin as comic relief after having a complete large amount of hefty abortion talk. However in Girls, the abortion talk could be the relief that is comic. The show’s second episode, “Vagina Panic,” is partially occur a Manhattan wellness center. Shoshanna, Marnie, and Hannah have indicated up to aid their 4th friend, flighty, pregnant Jessa (she’s the Samantha associated with the team). But Jessa’s too frightened — to attend the center herself. She spends the afternoon consuming White Russians and setting up by having complete stranger as her friends keep her increasingly aggravated messages like this: “Uh, hey. You’re expecting whenever you don’t desire to be. So that you may like to come get abortion now. Many Many Thanks.” Rather than segregating humor through the episode’s central issue, Girls finds humor for the reason that problem it self.

Even though both programs use frank language, Girls pushes the envelope by placing the expressed word“abortion” into its discussion whenever feasible. On SATC, the definition of it self is uttered simply 3 x; otherwise, it is just implied. Girls, but, has its own characters state “abortion” 11 times. Dunham might be attempting to surprise watchers into laughing; she additionally could be attempting to desensitize us into the word, therefore erasing a number of the stigma it holds. In either case, her show’s characters — from their attitudes with their language — are far more bold than their Manolo-wearing ancestors. Her show also is not afraid to tackle abortion through the get-go, in place of waiting four years.

But although the Girls are bold, they’re also woefully ignorant. None of the women has much experience with intercourse, let alone its effects; Hannah, the show’s Carrie equivalent, tries to determine then comparing herself to the pictures that she finds if she has an STD by Googling “diseases that come from no condom for one second. Miranda does not proceed through together with her abortion because she’s carefully weighed the professionals and cons of hot latin wife experiencing a child; Jessa, having said that, inadvertently discovers that she’s either got her duration or perhaps is having a convenient miscarriage, which frees her from needing to choose into the place that is first. (Unlike the ending of “Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda,” this one does feel just like a cop-out.)

Girls, then, is a show that’s both more audacious and less assured than Intercourse additionally the City. Possibly it is due to the fact its characters are young and sheltered; perhaps while the show continues, Hannah, Marnie, Shoshanna, and Jessa will quickly keep a closer resemblance to Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte, and Samantha. Having watched the show’ very first three episodes, this appears not likely. But either method, it is unjust to help keep comparing the two — since this duo of abortion episodes shows, their similarities are nearly completely shallow. (Well, all excepting one: Both programs function several of the most characters that are self-centered conceived for TV.)